Expert Determination
What is expert determination
Expert determination is a private, contractually based dispute resolution process in which the parties appoint an independent expert to decide a dispute of a technical nature. Unlike arbitration or litigation, the expert reaches a decision on the basis of their own technical expertise and the material presented by the parties, without formal hearings.
It is faster, more confidential and considerably more cost-effective than court proceedings, and is particularly suited to disputes that turn on technical questions rather than questions of law.
Accreditation with Resolution Institute
Tim Cousins is accredited as an expert determiner with the Resolution Institute, the peak membership body for dispute resolution practitioners across Australia and New Zealand. The Resolution Institute administers expert determination rules and maintains a panel of accredited determiners.
Appointments may be made directly by agreement between the parties, or through the Resolution Institute's appointment service. Visit the Resolution Institute
Disputes suited to expert determination
We accept appointments from insurers, legal practitioners and government agencies in disputes including:
- Origin and cause disputes arising from fires, explosions and engineering failures.
- Quantum disputes involving technical questions of damage, repairability and reinstatement.
- Product liability and recall matters, including product-failure root cause disagreements.
- Disputes under insurance policies turning on technical triggers, exclusions or causation.
- Electrical and electronic failure disputes, from switchboard, transformer and battery energy-storage fires to component-level failures in control systems, power electronics and consumer devices.
- Material and mechanical failure disputes in commercial, industrial and infrastructure contexts.
- Data centre incidents, including fire, water and electrical damage to critical infrastructure, cooling and power-train failures, and disputes over contamination, damage assessment and the recoverability of servers, switchgear and plant. These matters typically involve high values, tight restoration timelines and finely balanced technical questions of repair versus replacement, which makes an independent expert determination with written reasons particularly well suited.
The process
- Referral. The parties agree to refer the dispute to expert determination, either under an existing contract clause or by a standalone agreement.
- Appointment. We complete a conflict check and are appointed on agreed terms, directly or through the Resolution Institute.
- Submissions. The parties exchange submissions and supporting technical material on an agreed timetable.
- Enquiry. We may put written questions to the parties and, where useful, conduct a site or evidence inspection.
- Determination. A determination is issued with written reasons.
The determination
All determinations are issued with written reasons, so the parties can see precisely how the technical conclusions were reached. Whether a determination is binding is a matter for the parties' agreement; most expert determination clauses provide that the determination is final and binding except in the case of manifest error.
To discuss whether expert determination is suitable for your dispute, contact Simone Steers, Practice Manager
Expert Determination Enquiry